Talon Thoth vs Horus

[Gremlin]

The Desert Eagle Talon of Thoth is one of the more sought after weapons in the game but I'm looking at the Desert Eagle Talon of Horus and it seems to have better stats. Thoth has better mana regen but Horus more Dex, Dodge and Crit. Can someone please explain the the advantages thoth has over Horus and which Talon is better.


Desert Eagle Talon of Thoth
Req: Level 45, 142 Dex 56-61 Damage, 0.6 Speed, 8 Int, 3% Crit, 6 M/s Max Level 45

Desert Eagle Talon of Horus
Req: Level 45, 142 Dex 56-61 Damage, 0.6 Speed, 8 Dex, 3% Dodge, 6% Crit Max Level 45

[juhnken773]

Thoth is win.

Pot or no pot?

[KingFu]

Depends, do you need M/S or crit and dodge? If you're a pure archer, best would be Horus talon+X2 isis+X1 thoth, since it's the cheaper way out. If you're a dextress, 4 thoth, or 3 thoth 1 isis, s thoth talon. Also, as a dex bear, I'd go 3 isis 1 thoth.

We need a bit more information, like what class, what other gear you'd use with it, you're attributes, blah blah blah.

[Arterra]

I saw in the shop two Thoth goin for less than a Horus...

[Gremlin]

I'm a pure dex archer currently at level 48. The Thoth Talon is great for saving mana but the higher dex, crit, and dodge of the Horus Talon is hard to resist. For PvE mana pots are not a big deal since making money in higher level dungeons is relatively easy. I have not played PvP so I don't know the rules. If pots are not allowed in PvP then I can see the Thoth Talon having the advantage (without mana all toons become ordinary).

On a side note are elixirs allowed in PvP (hope not)?



str: 2
int : 1
dex: 250
Crit: 46
Dodge: 40 (was 39 yesterday )
HP: 251
HR: 18
MR 0
Damage 100 - 105
DPS: 170
Armor: 108


Head: Scorpion elm of Isis
Weapon: Desert Eagle Talon of Horus
Chest: Scorpion Leather of Isis
Shield: Menes Wing of Isis

[Raxie]

i would rather use the thoth talon for any occasion.