Samsung Galaxy S III or iPhone 5 - opinions wanted

[JaytB]

Hi all,


Since I'm still sporting an iPhone 4, I figured it might be time to upgrade to a better device.

I'm doubting between 2 devices, the Samsung Galaxy SIII or the iPhone 5.


I would like to know if the things listed below are easily achievable on a Samsung SIII:

* quick way to get an overview of new mails from various (around 5) different E-mail addresses, preferably from the lockscreen. I use a jailbreak tool to get a nice overview of new mail on my lockscreen with the ability to read/delete new mail without unlocking my phone.
* The mail app should be able to display a consolidated inbox showing me all my new mail from my various E-mail addresses. Preferably they should be able to be grouped according to other criteria (like flags, or specific E-mail addresses).
* I like reading specific websites on my phone in full screen (I use a jailbreak tool too to get safari in fullscreen). Is it easy to go fullscreen on the SIII browser?
* I'd like to stream video's from my home PC to my phone from anywhere there's an Internet connection. I use an app called AirVideo for this (only available on iOS). I'd also like to be able to display those video's on a normal television set, with the use of some cable or docking station.

So yeah, since I'm a complete Android noob, I was wondering if the things mentioned above are easily achievable on the Galaxy SIII?

Since I've always owned an iPhone, I bought tons of apps on there. So, I'm leaning more towards iPhone 5 at the moment. In current benchmark and durability tests, the iPhone also tops the SIII in just about any area. The only reason I would want to switch to a Samsung is the big screen (although it also lost in therms of quality vs the iPhone 5 screen in a very recent test).

So yeah, any feedback is welcome. I'm trying to figure out if the SIII and android, could be for me or not.


I hope this thread isn't going to turn out in another Android vs iOS flamewar LOL.

[dudetus]

Buy Samsung Galaxy SIII - the best iPhone.

[Growwle]

Android gives you more control over you phone but iOS is seemingly more secure. I would go with the iPhone 5, since Apple is going to litigate Samsung out of the smartphone business.

[Noodleleg]

I'd do iPhone 5 because you can iCloud sync everything to your new phone... Instead of restarting from scratch on a new type of device...

[CrimsonTider]

You know I am an Android fan, but if you have a lot of music/apps tied up through iTunes, I would stick with the iPhone.

However, this is why I don't use Apple so I don't have to worry about this issue.

[Cahaun]

I'm not sure I can say much as mine is a Samsung Galaxy S Fascinate

[Otukura]

In response to your question, yes, they all are. I'd suggest getting a different browser anyway, as they're a huge improvement in speed.

[Piosidon]

iPhone cause it's very simple to use

[zappaxe]

iPhone all the way. Much better imo.

[Ardon]

Possibly the SGS3.
I'm personally waiting on the new Nexus to come out until I get a new phone.

[TANKKAAR]

How I feel about Apple is summed up right here...lol

[Growwle]

I'd do iPhone 5 because you can iCloud sync everything to your new phone... Instead of restarting from scratch on a new type of device...

If you use Google for your contacts and email, you can import the data to an Android too.

[YYZ????]

Messed around with both the last couple days. Samsung screen is pretty sweet, I could not tell if it was lesser quality.


I am an iphone guy so there are certain things that I liked better about the iphone.


If I am not mistaken you are in the ERP business? One thing you may want to consider is how the ERP systems you use interface with the different devices. The system we are going to allow's limited functionality through mobile apps.

[bronislav84]

It has all that if you look hard enough, but let me tell you something you might be overlooking or forgetting: If you're a longstanding iCrap user, you will lose access to ALL your paid apps. All of them. I want to tell you to get the S3, but I don't want you to have to re-buy all your apps.

Btw S3 out benches i5. It has to because of better processors. Maybe they compared to the American S3, which I think still beats the i5 but not sure, but the European one simply can't be beat out. It's a quad core phone.

[shadow90]

It has all that if you look hard enough, but let me tell you something you might be overlooking or forgetting: If you're a longstanding iCrap user, you will lose access to ALL your paid apps. All of them. I want to tell you to get the S3, but I don't want you to have to re-buy all your apps.

Btw S3 out benches i5. It has to because of better processors. Maybe they compared to the American S3, which I think still beats the i5 but not sure, but the European one simply can't be beat out. It's a quad core phone.

Actually iPhone 5 beat Samsung Galaxy SIII in benchmarks.

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2410034,00.asp

[BodMaster]

I have the international SGIII, and I can't say that I could have chosen a better device. Got it on the day of release and not given me any trouble what-so ever.

US users are getting the short end of the stick, you would need to import to see the gain of the Quadcore on International version.

That said, if you have put a small fortune into your apps/music etc you are most likely better of staying with iOS. (But only knowing this will continue, meaning sometimes better to jump of the bandwagon before it's too late)

Haven't looked into your specific requirements, but anything is possible if rooted. If I have time will check it out and give you a heads up.

[BodMaster]

Actually iPhone 5 beat Samsung Galaxy SIII in benchmarks.http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2410034,00.asp

US version, Bron is talking about International version do you not listen?

[WarlordBears]

Samsung Galaxy S III no regrets!

[HunterSLAYER]

Just look at the quote under my sig and you will know which is best for ya ^^

[HunterSLAYER]

US version, Bron is talking about International version do you not listen?

He's brainwashed by Apple, don't waste your breath explaining to fanboys.