Its entirely situation based. I know plenty of avid item hoarder/collectors that have too much money and are on the hunt for items like the originals. Just like a car collector, he's not gonna want the "look alike", he's going to spend big money on the original to gloat about it later. Yes, other people won't spend the extra on an item that looks exactly the same but unless originals start popping up in the AH selling for similar prices, I don't see them being exactly the same price as the 2014 and 2013 ones; IMHO. If you're willing to ask for the big bucks, you're going to have to be patient and find the person willing to spend the big bucks for your rare item.