What old school item that you can't get would you like to see brought back?

[Gluttony]

I'd like to see the costumes make a comeback, at least human since there are no other real humans in the game. Other than that, perhaps Big Luck (I know plenty of players would pick that for the permaluck re-roll).

Yes, but if people know that sometime in the future they might be able to get the same items again, they won't jump on it as desperately. In case you haven't noticed, a lot of people buy things right away bc they just HAVE to collect them all. Without that sense of it being a limited time item, ppl won't be as quick to buy. I assume, after all, that STS wants their vanity items to sell...

That's a very good point and I would have to say that the Big Luck item would probably sell just as well (if not better) than the initial sales simply based on the fact that players have seen the item in action; consider it a long-term demonstration.

Edit: Better yet, why not a male's version of the Big Luck (I know that the ears weren't solely for females, but they were a bit feminine).