Hmm....so let's pretend in BS that an enemy has 120 armor.
When equipped on my dual spec build with a 1 dodge, 9 armor ring, Royal Sewer BFH has 183-213 dmg (198 avg), the Gurgox has 214-299 (251 avg)
(Effective damage = Avg weapon damage - enemy armor)
Gurg Hammer effective damage = 251-120 = 131
Royal Sewer BFH effective damage = 198-120 = 78
Gurg Hammer true effective DPS = Effective dmg/weap speed = 131/1.4 = 93.6
Royal Sewer BFH true effective DPS = 78/1.0 = 78
So even with slow-as-dirt speed, Gurg Hammer beats the Royal Sewer BFH. I know the Sewer has some procs though, I forget which.
Royal Sewer BFH = higher dodge, h/s, armor
Gurg = higher hit, crit, more "true" DPS
Bookmarks