Crafted Lilith wand/bracer vs Demonic W/B set - a detailed comparison

[JaytB]

I finally got lucky enough to be able to buy the last piece for my lv65 int set (darn hard to find lv65 robe :/), and decided to craft it. I was wondering how it stacked up against demonic.

Since I think that many people are wondering the same thing, I decided to write this post. This way, anyone can make an informed decision on the exact differences between these two awesome sets, and decide if it’s worth to spend time and/or gold on.


Here are both sets next to one another with their respective stats…


http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/ce646d61.jpg http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/6979ef5b.jpg

Unless you like the flintstones, I’d say looks are way better for demonic (except maybe for the glowing eyes on the Lilith set). But I’ll just stay objective and say, opinions may vary :)


Below, you’ll find the stats summed up, and at the end, a summary of the differences.


Please note that the Demonic stats are for a 61 mage, while Lilith are taken from a 66 mage. So, while not 100% correct, it should give you a fairly accurate comparison.

Stats for Wand/Bracer at lv61 (Demonic) and Lv66 (Lilith) are:

Demonic/Lilith/Difference

Int : 405/413 (438 -25 (5x5int) for being lv 66))/8 int

Hit : 106/109/3 hit (possibly from int increase)

Crit : 29/42/13 crit

Dodge : 7/7/-

Health : 400/400/-

H/s : 36/32/-4 H/s

Mana : 802/819/17 Mana (possibly because of being lvl 66)

M/s : 28/37/9 M/s (possibly only 8 M/s, because of level difference)

Dmg : 203-248/221-266/18 Dmg

Dps : 225/244/19 Dps

Armor: 162/191/29

Lightning dmg: 293-440/315-468/22-28 dmg


Summary of differences in stats for Demonic vs Lilith

Below, I only highlighted the stats that shouldn’t have been impacted by the lvl differences too much

Lilith vs Demonic: +8 int, +3 hit, 17 Mana, -4 H/s, +9m/s, +13 crit, +18 min/max Dmg, +19 Dps, +29 armor, +22-28 skill dmg


Closing comments

With the lvl66 vanity sets and a ring, stats look more interesting:

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/43e938af.jpg


The 66 vanity set, makes the set looks much better as compared to the flintstones look, in my personal opinion. But, I’ll let you be the judge of that:

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/a32e5c88.jpg http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/b3696e02.jpg

Please leave your constructive feedback below :)

[Kaytar]

Oh wow new crafted is way better than demonic.I'm getting it!!!

[Gaunab]

Nice comparison :)

Off topic: You were looking for this robe. Have you bought it from someone who got it before the weekend or did it drop to you/ a mate of yours recently..?

[Cytokinesis]

Off topic: You were looking for this robe. Have you bought it from someone who got it before the weekend or did it drop to you/ a mate of yours recently..?
Lilith is crafted

[Whirlzap]

Wha-what...
Look at the Enchanted-Demonic increases.
Now look at Demonic-Lilith stat increases.
From Enchanted to Demonic, the stat increased a little:/
From Demonic to Lilith, the stat increased ALOT.

[JaytB]

Off topic: You were looking for this robe. Have you bought it from someone who got it before the weekend or did it drop to you/ a mate of yours recently..?

Since nothing dropped, I had to buy it from someone. Don't ask me for how much I bought it for though, it was way overpriced for a robe. But I just HAD to finish my set somehow LOL :D

[Paar]

I like How Neat and Organized You do things Jay! Very Good Job(: *Claps* Great Comparrison I like how theres alot more armor and Dmg!

[Gaunab]

Lilith is crafted

I know, but therefor it requires a lvl65 lilith robe. Jay posted a thread that He was looking for one.
Im just asking out of curiosity, since i havent seen any lvl65 pinks this Weekend. If it was dropped recently, that would at least prove that there ARE still chances of getting pinks :)

[Gaunab]

Since nothing dropped, I had to buy it from someone. Don't ask me for how much I bought it for though, it was way overpriced for a robe. But I just HAD to finish my set somehow LOL :D

Thanks for the answer, even if that wasn't what I was hoping for... :)

(excuse double-posting pls)

[JaytB]

I like How Neat and Organized You do things Jay! Very Good Job(: *Claps* Great Comparrison I like how theres alot more armor and Dmg!

Thanks! Appreciate it :)



Thanks for the answer, even if that wasn't what I was hoping for... :)

(excuse double-posting pls)

I know what you mean, no changes in drop rates yet, but as stated in the other thread devs will definitely get back to us about it :)

[Irulelol]

Someone needs to do this with dex demonic and new sets to convince some peole to get rid of there demonic stuff at cheaper prices XD

[Cytokinesis]

Someone needs to do this with dex demonic and new sets to convince some peole to get rid of there demonic stuff at cheaper prices XD
lmao ikr? :)

[JaytB]

Someone needs to do this with dex demonic and new sets to convince some peole to get rid of there demonic stuff at cheaper prices XD

If you could borrow me one, I'd do it ;)

[Yvonnel]

Thanks JaytB! I bet you knocked a big dent in your wallet too!!!!!

[JaytB]

Thanks JaytB! I bet you knocked a big dent in your wallet too!!!!!

Well... Anything for the community.. (or my impatience LOL :D )

[Elitephonix]

Wow Looks like mages will rule lev 65 pvp
And I think the crafted lev 65 is better but demonics looks much cooler

[JaytB]

Wow Looks like mages will rule lev 65 pvp
And I think the crafted lev 65 is better but demonics looks much cooler

Well, couldn't sleep very well so decided to try it in PvP. I consider myself not really good with mage, since I'm used to PvP with my bird. But wow, I beat some very good players from different classes. So that must mean it's good :)

[Walkhardd]

Thanks for the comparison! I think its going to be very hard to top the looks of demonic..but with vanity set, it looks pretty sweet! And over 200 armor looks like I can go back to pure int :)

[jiroununu]

Well, couldn't sleep very well so decided to try it in PvP. I consider myself not
really good with mage, since I'm used to PvP with my bird. But wow, I beat some very good players from different classes. So that must mean it's good :)

Im not sure how this set against bear in pvp. Because with crafted orlak set I have 60dodge and 70crit buffed. I vote warbird will still have overal advantage against any class with crafted orlak set.
Btw what's the weapon proc of that wand? And what about Lilith staff?

[JaytB]

Im not sure how this set against bear in pvp. Because with crafted orlak set I have 60dodge and 70crit buffed. I vote warbird will still have overal advantage against any class with crafted orlak set.
Btw what's the weapon proc of that wand? And what about Lilith staff?

Warbirds are always tough cookies lol. Have only fought one in demonic, and could win that fairly easy. Just took some time.

As for the proc, it procs nightmare with weakness. This helps getting armor and dodge down. Would love to try it out on an Orlok warbird though :)

[jiroununu]

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l529/jirou123/8ce4654a.jpg

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l529/jirou123/415e53b8.jpg

Enjoy

[jiroununu]

Btw I equipped a 2crit 10damage ring in the pics

[JaytB]

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l529/jirou123/8ce4654a.jpg

http://i1122.photobucket.com/albums/l529/jirou123/415e53b8.jpg

Enjoy

Thanks for the pics! Love stats lol :)

And wow, that might be a tough cookie to crack with my mage, especially on a warbird IMO.

Would you mind telling me you min-max stomp dmg?

[WhoIsThis]

Overall, the stats seem to be moving in the direction of each set getting more specialized.

It's a good decision. Less stats wasted on useless H/S, more on useful M/S. Improvements in crit and damage, along with armor.

On the str set, the emphasis is strictly on survivability and the improvement overall is less than that of the int set. Probably needed as the str set was a bit OP in 60-61. I fear though that the int set maybe a bit OP relative to the others. Time will tell.

[Tetraeder]

Nice comparison :)

Off topic: You were looking for this robe. Have you bought it from someone who got it before the weekend or did it drop to you/ a mate of yours recently..?

Since nothing dropped, I had to buy it from someone. Don't ask me for how much I bought it for though, it was way overpriced for a robe. But I just HAD to finish my set somehow LOL :D

Hey it was not "overpriced", the price was fair (hehe) because it is a super rare robe.
The robe dropped yesterday (I dont saw it myself).

Thanks JaytB, for your work to the community :-)

[jiroununu]

Thanks for the pics! Love stats lol :)

And wow, that might be a tough cookie to crack with my mage, especially on a warbird IMO.

Would you mind telling me you min-max stomp dmg?

Stomp damage 304-325

[Pakax]

Thanks Jay - much appreciated.

Would love to see the demonic stats on a 66 mage to compare apples to apples tho (that is, if you still have your demonic gear...)

[cajunqueen]

At least the lillith set put stockings on the legs...LOL....don't like the "short" robe for those of us who are modest....
Nice stats on the crafted set...just need the pinks to drop so I can start crafting!!!
Thanks J !

[Whirlzap]

Warbirds are easy with STAFF pure mages.
There's no point in defending against them unless you're a pally yourself.

[JaytB]

Stomp damage 304-325

Thanks! Exactly what I wanted to know. Seems skill dmg has improved for bears. Together with the fairly high crit, looks like a great amount of extra dmg can be dealt with current str gear :)


Thanks Jay - much appreciated.

Would love to see the demonic stats on a 66 mage to compare apples to apples tho (that is, if you still have your demonic gear...)

Sorry, don't have my demonic set anymore. I'll see if someone in my guild still has a set that I could try :)

[JaytB]

I went ahead and got the Lilith staff to complete the entire set.

I'll post the detailed comparison tomorrow or so (getting late here), but I wanted to share the main differences with demonic already :)

Demonic staff set:

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/60d46b77.jpg


Crafted Lilith staff set:

http://i1081.photobucket.com/albums/j344/JaytB1/48d67cf9.jpg


Main differences in stats crafted Lilith vs Demonic:

+10% crit, +28 health pool, -1 H/s, +7 M/s, +33-44 dmg (min-max), +61 dps, +14 armor, +24-30 skill dmg (min-max)