PDA

View Full Version : Boycott Scatterbears: A short rant by a proper tank.



gotrocks420
03-15-2012, 07:20 AM
I have been doing lots of balefort sewer runs lately, as I've just hit level 50 recently. I'd like to immediately point out that I'm no pro - clearly I dont have a level 66, I'm not running with uber gear, and I dont know everything there is to know about PL, including tanking. But one of the first things I did when I started playing PL was read the forums.

I noticed that my chosen class (the bear) was probably one of the more difficult classes to play. I didn't do a lot of damage, and really I didnt seem to stay alive THAT much longer than other classes. Dang, I thought to myself, I really chose wrong! I knew the bear was supposed to be a tank and not damage dealer, but it seemed like my poor bear eas useless in both categories. So I turned to the forums around my first week or so of playing, and found (I think it was Tankaar) Tankaar's guide to being a tank in balefort sewers.

Now first off, balefort sewers sounded crazy difficult and complicated. I instantly wanted to be there. But it was a long way off. Still, i thought i could glean some knowledge from the jnfo provided and apply it to the earlier stages. Boy am i glad i did. I learned alot. My idea of what a tank is/was in PL was way off, and it turns out being a tank in PL is just as difficult as your average pc MMO.

Much like other MMO's, being a tank in PL involves constantly being aware of whats going on, always being in the front, and always maintaining control. Unlike other MMO's crowd control and mob placement is solely a bears responsibility. Without a good bear doing what hes supposed to be doing (among other things, chugging potions), high level non-elixired runs quickly turn to s***. I was a little overwhelmed at first, but the concept is relatively simple. Find mobs, taunt, find wall/corner, beckon into it, stomp them into wall/corner, then hellscream. CB the hardest hitting mobs if possible. Repeat if necessary. It took me a little while to get this down consistantly (admittedly I didnt really start doing this until halfway into AO2, and had it down by AO3), but once I did, runs went so smoothly. The mages/birds who knew how to play often thanked me or sent friend requests, and my gameplay experience improved greatly. I finally felt like my bear was worth something, and my many hours of play were paying off. I'd occasionally run into a bear who liked to screw things up, often somehow hitting beckon at the exact moment i did (read: think newtons law, only fubar'd and on aliens), but it seemed few and far between, and often times the offending bear would listen when i explained why we beckon into walls/corners, and either stop screwing off or stop beckoning altogether. Finally i managed to hit level 50, arm myself with mystery armor and helm, and march off to Balefort Sewers, a big grin on my face for finally making it to a REAL run. The horrors i experienced there will leave scars that run deep.

Its not that the sewers are particularly difficult - sure, some of the bosses can be tough, and those dam exploding grates are a pain - but overall the difficulty of the trash mobs is only mediocre. With ironblood, evade, and taunt running, I could survive all but the largest groups of mobs without even downing a potion. Even with ironblood and evade off, taunt, hellscream, a strategically placed cb and a heal from a mage were usually enough to get through any encounter unscathed. Until i met my mortal enemy... The scatterbear.

You've all seen them. You've all read about them. They run around flailing their arms, hitting beckon like a fat kid hits his mother when she wont buy him candy. They spam stomp like they are listening to 'hammer time' and the world will end if they dont stop - spammer time - everytime stomp pops up. They think taunt is a waste of time. Their rntire focus is on doing whatever the hell they want because 'they can play the game their way', which is fine if they are playing solo. But this is like saying you can go into a crowded airport and just start screaming that noise jim carrey makes in dumb and dumber 'because u can'. Sure, you can absolutely do that, but just like in PL, in real life you are part of a society, and generally speaking that society doesnt like obnoxious people. If you did that IRL people would think youre either insane, mentally handicapped, or just plain rude, obnoxious, and dumb. Someone would probably politely ask you to stop, maybe multiple someones, and if you kept going eventually you could even be arrested for causing a disturbance. A minor crime, to be sure, but one that would still require people in uniforms with guns to come and tell you to shut the f*** up. Or some good samaratin with a strong right hook would just knock you out. Whichever came first.

Unfortunately, in PL, the equivalent of the police or a fist in the face is the 'boot' button. Something i rarely have control over as i tend to not host games, it can be hard for me to get a full run going late at night when im usually playing, so i just join one instead. And when that scatterbear walks in, theres nothing i can do. Oftentimes these are pick up games, and there is no host or the host doesnt care. The worst part about the scatterbear is their arrogance. Being ignorant of something is always ok - id never fault someone for genuinely not understanding what they are supposed to be doing - but when someone politely explains to you how to effectively play your class (and lets be honest, bears are really only good at this one thing) and you ignore it, or worse, tell them they are wrong, you cross from ignorance into stupidity. Here are some sample responses ive recieved in my short time in the sewers:
"shutup noob"

"i can play how i want noob, u just suck"

"f u. Ur bear is awful u dont kno what ur talking about"

And these arent even the worst ones. The guy who made that last comment actually ended up deciding to check out the tank guide. He admitted he didnt want to at first because he didnt need a guide to tell him how to play. And also that he didnt like to read. For some reason, I wasnt surprised.

This has become so common im starting to get frustrated at PL. You may ask why i even care. The simple answer is this: i worked hard to build a bear centered around tanking. I spent many hours learning how to do it properly so that i could make runs move quickly and efficiently, so that everything dies, people earn fast xp, and im the only one chugging potions. For someone to waltz in and utterly fail at their chosen class (most dont even have taunt) and simultaneously ruin the task of mine is very frustrating. Im not trying to say this is the end of the world, and im not some elitest prick who thinks hes better than everyone else (im clearly not), but if youre going to invest hours and hours into getting a character to level 50, i think you should know how to play your class, or gtfo. This s*** wouldnt fly in a traditional MMO, but i think it happens here because this one is free. Also, i feel the average age of the player base is a little younger (im not saying kids are arrogant and stupid its just.... Well, yes, actually im saying that most of them are. I was once 11 too).

Someone please save me. If youre still running balefort sewers, boycott scatterbears. Explain politely how to tank properly, or point them to the tank guide. If they give some smart-assed reply or ignore you, boot them with reason: lrn2tank/read/think/listen/lrn. If this happens enough these idiots will finally get it. In the meantime, if you have a character still running.sewers and need a smart, slightly funny(sometimes), on the ball tank who knows what hes doing, go ahead and send me a request and lets do some leveling-farming. This old grizzly bear would greatly appreciate it (k so im not that old, but having two kids certainly makes me feel that way). And show those scatterbears they need to shape up and listen to the people who know that your underwear goes UNDERNEATH your pants, not over them (unless youre superman, in which case you can do whatever the f*** you want. Or Chuck Norris).

BOYCOTT SCATTERBEARS!!!


IGN:Gotrocks. - 51 Tank
gotstorms - 35 glass cannon
gotguns - 5 paper handgun

***edit*** my appologies for typos, i was doing this on my phone so kinda hard to go back and edit spelling. Also, understand that this was meant to be a little overdramatic, or else it wouldnt really be interesting. Scatterbears havent ruined my real life, they are just really, really annoying, and do screw up my enjoyment of the game. Thanks.for reading my 'short' rant :)

Xionskull
03-15-2012, 07:36 AM
Wow, I'm switching back to bear. I saw a lvl 54 beat clear boggy waters. O.O

Actona679
03-15-2012, 10:09 AM
but if youre going to invest hours and hours into getting a character to level 50, i think you should know how to play your class

Oh, I wish.

I too started a bear (twice) and each time became so frustrated with others players understanding of what their "jobs" are in combination with a tank, that I abandoned it. I think the bear is the hardest character to play of all of them. I have a love/hate relationship with bears. They can make a run a joyous bloodbath and save my little bird feathers from certain death OR they can scatter the mobs about with such abandonment that I hardly know where I am shooting or what is shooting at me so I end up dead, dead, dead. Long live the scatterbear :hopelessness:

One thing I will say is that I think the technique of bears at higher levels seems to be much better. I suspect this is because there are so many good players that won't tolerate a bad tank and they boot them. Or maybe I am just entering PUGs and getting lucky with good bears. But, for certain, lower level maps have too many bad ones. I absolutely cringe when more than one bear enters a dungeon. Certain death awaits. The swamps are an especially bad place to be with more than one scatterbear.

So - keep playing, GotRocks. We need more good tanks! Know that your experience will get better. Feel free to add one of my characters (shhh - add Magykx - level 56 mage - don't tell anyone it's me). I am running the sewers more than usual these days. I like the sewers. Nothing like exploding barrels and fire grates to get the blood stirring :tyrannosaurus:

gotrocks420
03-15-2012, 11:43 AM
Thanks guys! And thanks for the thanks. Its good to know that im not the only one that feels thid way :)

Cytokinesis
03-15-2012, 11:47 AM
Best Tanking Guide EVER: http://www.spacetimestudios.com/showthread.php?31389-How-to-be-a-good-Scatter-Bear

Coltona
03-15-2012, 11:53 AM
Ok well as far as "short rants" go i couldn't read this..lol it's a book

K after reading your post i am on your side, my first char was a bear who is now 57 and dual spec str/dex. I loved tanking with him, and at one time had tons of invites per game for a good tank, i know focus more on my pally getting 56 glyph drops, but i plan on making a return with my bear to show these youngsters how it's done, i'm not saying i'm the best either, and i'm not old enough to call them youngsters haha, but i was a scatterbear at one time (very shortly) too, and i'm glad i could learn the difference. Hey add my pally coltonadkins for sewer runs, i'm trying to farm a raid set for pvp and selling, working on recurve ATM.

Sryyoulose
03-15-2012, 11:54 AM
I I I I I Scatter bear! We'll when enemy's are in 2 opposite directions anyways. Also whenever I'm in a good group I make an effort not to scatter! Also theres also 2 good bears sometimes and we pull to different corners. Also if u ask me everyone has a little scatter bear in them. Don't hate thread no point we all know we hate scatter bears like me.

gotrocks420
03-15-2012, 12:23 PM
Best Tanking Guide EVER: http://www.spacetimestudios.com/showthread.php?31389-How-to-be-a-good-Scatter-Bear



Yes without a doubt LOL (For any newbs reading this DO NOT READ THAT GUIDE!)

And in response to sryyoulose, if there are two bears in a group i really believe there should be a designated tank so that things dont get confusing. The problem with trying to pull mobs into two seperate corners is that it doesnt really work that way. One bear pulls jnto one corner, the other bear tries to pull into another corner and ends up scattering all the mobs in between the two bears. Also, if theres two groups of mobs your party should really only be focusing on one. If you want to pull both groups its better to have one bear run in between the two and pull all the mobs into one corner. If you seperate the two groups youre basically having to divide your attention between the groups, and killing them slower. Or not at all. The bottom line is, you either need to have a designated tank or both tanks need to coordinate where they are going to pull the mobs so they dont end up scattering the mobs everywhere. Basically both bears need to be standing in the same place when they beckon.

Elyseon
03-15-2012, 12:28 PM
Rename: A looong rant xD

Rare
03-15-2012, 12:59 PM
OK, first let me start by saying i only read about half your novel. ;).

However, I feel your pain. scatter bears give all bears a very bad name. In fact, I've often been booted just for being the second bear. You gotta take the good with the bad.

IMO bears are the funnest class to play. When things go smoothly, it is awesome.

StompArtist
03-15-2012, 01:18 PM
Add me ign: Scatterbear

NECROREAPER
03-15-2012, 01:52 PM
Shoot me a request, I'll be glad to help you out


-PK

Fusionstrike
03-15-2012, 02:01 PM
And in response to sryyoulose, if there are two bears in a group i really believe there should be a designated tank so that things dont get confusing.

Really the only practical way to handle it is to have only one bear responsible for "first contact" gathering mobs and getting things set up. The other ones need to be cognizant of this and just stay out of the way. Once the mobs are gathered, the other bears could do a second taunt/stomp wave just to add to the stun effect, but basically they're just on mop-up duty at that point finishing the mobs off. At all costs, the other bears have to avoid screwing things up, so really I think the simplest thing to do is just don't ever hit beckon or stomp.

The easiest thing to do is have one bear be the lead for the whole run. If there are two bears who are good at coordinating, they can "leapfrog" each other, taking turns being first into each wave. A good rule for a bear is to keep track of any others and react accordingly. If the other bear is out in front, assume he's handling it and stay out of the way. If you're fortunate enough to have a competent player behind the other bear, he'll do the same when you're out in front. I've found a surprising amount of cooperation with other bears that works just like this, although it wasn't until I got near level cap. So take heart, there are better bears near endgame.

The other trick you can use is to try to stay in front aggressively. Even if you have an incompetent bear in the group, you can make it a point to move ahead to the next area very quickly so you can get things in hand before the other one can arrive and screw things up too badly. If you've already got the mobs collected and stunned before he arrives, odds are better he'll not be able to scatter them as badly.

JFelt8
03-15-2012, 02:06 PM
Yay the great pumpkin returns :)). Anyway same here bud, hit me up anytime I'll help out. No matter how stringy sewers was to me stronghold is one of my fav maps to tank.

Ign kylardordan

JFelt8
03-15-2012, 02:18 PM
For me pug running I'll lay back and off tank till I get a feel for my partner then its all realizing ur turn to taunt and help out on becon. N scatter bear situation I do aggressively lead and group before scatter beat can mess up.
Now n the case of running with friends like necro, hanko, and jj, we all know pretty much where the other is going cause we use most of the same beacon points. So we trade off taunts and double becon everything n the area to the same point. It's awesome to watch two ppl work and pull exact same time and no one n the mob gets away. Total destruction and fast. Those three r some of my favs to run with add my fav mage angel and some good birds, jj being and hanko being that too, and everything is utterly destroyed

Naonagotek
03-15-2012, 04:36 PM
Long live scatter bears!!

Pm me ing if u need any questions about tanking: scatterbear

JFelt8
03-15-2012, 04:46 PM
Lol love the name. Know some pretty good scatters myself lol. Mr str being the king lmao

MrKrone
03-15-2012, 04:55 PM
Op, i full heartedly support you and your wonderful rant.

My main toon is a 45 pure dex bird. I have spent a full two weeks leveling him with no elixers, using PUGs. 5 times out of 5.0001 times, there was a scatterbear. No matter what i told him, asked him, or anything'd (lol) him, they never stopped being a scatterbear. They have slowed down my progress in PL so much, that i honestly think i couldve been 66 and a half if these bears did their job right.

Before i ever play a mmo, i check the forums. Heading to the guides section, i saw guides on how to play each char, and their builds, so i chose which class i wanted by these guides. Looking at the bear, it seemed that he was an severely expert class, that required serious effort. This was not, and may never be the class for me. I knew that if i touched a bear, i would play him wrong, and cause your rant to occur. I knew i would f*** up so many peoples days. So i chose a bird.

That Was a wonderful rant, OP, and deserves a sticky in my honest opinion.

Appleisaac
03-15-2012, 04:58 PM
IGN:Gotrocks. - 51 Tank
gotstorms - 35 glass cannon
gotguns - 5 paper handgun


hey... :-/ dont call these guys out :( it isnt a sin to be a scatter bear :-/ it just isnt a very good strategy. plz edit and delete the names on here :)

MrKrone
03-15-2012, 05:01 PM
IGN:Gotrocks. - 51 Tank
gotstorms - 35 glass cannon
gotguns - 5 paper handgun


hey... :-/ dont call these guys out :( it isnt a sin to be a scatter bear :-/ it just isnt a very good strategy. plz edit and delete the names on here :)

Gotrocks420, OP, was not calling anyone out. He was putting HIS IGNs.

Appleisaac
03-15-2012, 05:01 PM
lol sorry XD i saw BOYCOT SCATTERBEARS above it and i thought they were igns of scatter bears ;)

MrKrone
03-15-2012, 05:05 PM
No problem, just be sure to read more carefully next time. :)

StompArtist
03-15-2012, 06:01 PM
lol sorry XD i saw BOYCOT SCATTERBEARS above it and i thought they were igns of scatter bears ;)

My ign IS Scatterbear

pocketlegendshq
03-15-2012, 06:01 PM
My ign IS Scatterbear

-_____-

Growwle
03-15-2012, 06:09 PM
Should not matter as long as DPS stay on your main target. Plus soloing as a bear would suck without stomp.

NECROREAPER
03-15-2012, 06:12 PM
Should not matter as long as DPS stay on your main target. Plus soloing as a bear would suck without stomp.

You know, way back in the day, bears didn't have the beckon+stomp combo. Imagine what it was like trying to tank back then ._.

gotrocks420
03-15-2012, 06:37 PM
lol sorry XD i saw BOYCOT SCATTERBEARS above it and i thought they were igns of scatter bears ;)

Lmao, i thiught you were poking fun at me :)

angeldawn
03-15-2012, 06:44 PM
....
Now n the case of running with friends like necro, hanko, and jj, we all know pretty much where the other is going cause we use most of the same beacon points. So we trade off taunts and double becon everything n the area to the same point. It's awesome to watch two ppl work and pull exact same time and no one n the mob gets away. Total destruction and fast. Those three r some of my favs to run with add my fav mage angel and some good birds, jj being and hanko being that too, and everything is utterly destroyed

Kylar your right these are some great bears to run with!!

Just to add a few more Conanursan, Sirpnut and Apollo (although Apollo can def be a scatter bear lol)

And yes we can def kick some butt together :-)

Fyrce
03-15-2012, 09:42 PM
Actually bears are great to play. However, since their skills generally dictate that they lead, playing a bear requires more thinking. Leading can be draining. If you cannot do this, take a break.

Second, there are ways to play with a scatterbear. Yes, the easiest way really is not to play with them ***Duck***, but when you do encounter one, and you will, you'll need to adjust your play style to work with them.

The simplest way to do this, if you are able, is to stay ahead of the group AND the scatterbear, thus starting your gather before the other bear can come mess it up. Beckon DOES do some damage as does stomp, so you can hope that even if your group follows that other bear, together, the enemies can be killed even with a scatterbear.

If you are lucky, a few teammates will get the idea and follow you closely, thus getting in some combos and kills before the scatterbear arrives. Scatterbear can then be a clean-up bear, where scattering is not such a bad thing.

If you are unable to keep ahead of Scatterbear, you can compliment him. Since you are a bear, you can wait for the scatter and THEN gather. Don't forget that stomp DOES do damage. Again, if your team clues in, you can still clear pretty quickly, even WITH a scatterbear.

Learning to work with a scatterbear can actually improve your skills. You have to pay more attention, rather than just run around like a robot.

Anyways, just saying...

NECROREAPER
03-15-2012, 10:40 PM
tl;dr

~hope i helped. thank if u like ~ sign


You're annoying, go away

zeusabe
03-15-2012, 10:41 PM
Very nice read and I agree on every point. In support to your call, I'd like to let you know that I host 100% of my runs and one of my "boot" criteria have been scatterbears...If booting scatterbears gives gold, I'd be filthy rich now LOL. I put "tank prprly" in my boot reason. Anyway, this is probably one of the best (if not the best) and most heart-felt write-up regarding Scatter Bears that I've seen. Rep!

gotrocks420
03-16-2012, 12:11 AM
Fyrce, thank you for the excellent advice, i will take what you said and use it.

To everyone else; thank you for reading my 'short' rant and taking the time to respond. I look forward i look forward to playing with all of you soon!

And if you liked this write up hit the thanks button lol :)

and somebody buy my lvl 21 crystalline str shield helm.and.sword so i dont have to be poor anymore (shameless plug for my items LOL)

gotrocks420
03-21-2012, 07:10 AM
Should not matter as long as DPS stay on your main target. Plus soloing as a bear would suck without stomp.



Nothing wrong with stomp, just do it into a wall (unless youre solo). I truly believe scattering mobs all over the screen is not only obnoxious, its counter productive to tanking, and makes runs take longer (and sometimes even wipes the group)

havent been on in a few days, took a mini break after i posted this; but i added everyone who left their ign. Hope to play with you all soon

wvhills
03-21-2012, 07:49 AM
If you can't beat them, join them. Bwahahahahahaha (evil laugh).

kiitz
03-21-2012, 03:31 PM
Gotrocks,

I think most people who play bears (and actually all 3 classes) and visit the forums know your pain. I've been through it too and really all I can say is, hang in there buddy! While you are still leveling, its going to be a pain because along the way you will meet other great players, add them to your friend list, try to play with them as much as possible, only to find that you've either out leveled them or they have out leveled you. Or perhaps they don't ever really show up too much after playing with them.

All this changes after you reach the "end game". At that point you just start looking for other quality players to run with and possibly try to join a guild, which then formalizes it even more.

Playing as bear, you are naturally going to be leading the group. Go ahead and host games then and kick the players you do not enjoy playing with. The reality of it is, if you have 3 decent players (including yourself) in the group of 5, you can basically carry 2 randoms. The standard process is then "remaking" whatever you are running while your 2 friends join you. You will pick up a different random player or two each time and if you find they are doing a great job, add them and ask them if they would like to continue remaking with you guys. Eventually, you'll have a solid group of 5 to keep doing runs with before people have to go. Rinse and repeat.

If you are a good bear, other players will naturally want to run with you and join your games since you will be making the runs smooth n easy.

Elyseon
03-21-2012, 03:47 PM
Yeh, bears over use beckon, just cuz u can use it doesnt mean you should.
Should mages just spam resurect all the time? (Sadly theres probably some of those too)

Matutd
03-21-2012, 03:58 PM
I know how u feel haha, I have a lvl 66 so I know how a bear should play, but I still had to learn how to play it. I recently got my bear to 50 and it is incredible how many bears can't play their class, and in most cases, refuse to listen to advice when ur trying to teach them in a polite manner. Trying to keep the team alive whilst having a scatter bear on the team is so hard, I think the tutorials should be made class specific, like they have all skills in tutorial and take a blow to the head or something and forget everything they knew, the tutorials could show bears how to beckon, birds to stay behind the tanks and deal damage, and mages how to keep the group alive, and heal. That way, people will have a bit of an idea about what is expected of them on the battlefield