Originally Posted by
FeralDruid
I have to disagree with the OP here. I think much of what is being said here can be interpreted with not being specced/geared for the way they want to play the class.
DPS comes with the sacrifice of tanking ability. Tanking comes with the sacrifice of DPS effectiveness. Warriors have skills to increase threat, crit percentage, as well as hp regen to mitigate the side effects of either spec.
Watch a PvP Warrior in WoW with amazing DPS/Crits try to tank End Game, the group will wipe on the first pull. Contrary, watch a Tank Warrior try to PvP and laugh as he gets owned by the classes they are designed to be hard counters for. In both cases, the Warriors are specced and geared for the way they want to play, and that is very much the case here in PL in a general sense.