Originally Posted by
Aoeqt
I hate to disagree but being able to reserve an original name means that they have been playing for a long time and deserve to continue to have that name.
Take this for example, a player in PL named Argothewickd recently came back from a 2 year break. Was a very well know player and lots of people knew him. If the same thing was implied for that, then its almost as if the legacy was gone. Yes the name isn't rare but he made the name stand for something and should stay that way.