A small guild leaderboard suggestion.

**Andrisber** · 01-18-2015, 02:02 PM

Hi!

I have an idea, i dont know if it was said before but...

Guilds from leaderboards (1-50) officers and ofc, guild master, would get a banner (in end of the season) with a sceptre or something like that with the number of season (VII). New season is coming and i think that people would like this suggestion pretty much. +1 Leaderboard banner won't make a big difference in the size of AL, because many banners come every season.

Have a nice day.

-Productive

**Serancha** · 01-18-2015, 02:47 PM

This would make everyone flock to the top 50 guilds just for end-of-season. Then they would get their banners and go back to their normal guilds.

This suggestion has been made several times before and was rejected by the devs. Too many logistical issues involved.

**Andrisber** · 01-18-2015, 03:19 PM

Originally Posted by Serancha

This would make everyone flock to the top 50 guilds just for end-of-season. Then they would get their banners and go back to their normal guilds.

This suggestion has been made several times before and was rejected by the devs. Too many logistical issues involved.

Which guild would give officer instantly? I was in Magnum/Purple Thunder for about 1.6 years and i got officer before a week or so. Recruiters DONT get a banner

**Serancha** · 01-18-2015, 03:53 PM

Giving it to just officers and GM's would add to the already-large problem of guild segregation. I know a lot of guilds don't see members as equal to ranked members, in the sense that officers only run with officers and use /o instead of /g most of the time. I was in a guild like that once, and have heard that it is still the norm in a lot of guilds.

Giving banners to those who are already often treated as (or consider themselves) "better" than others in the guild would just enhance this problem and make everyone else feel left out. After all, it's the members who get the guild it's ranking. If it were just officers, these top guilds would not be "top".

**Jack O Reaper** · 01-18-2015, 04:11 PM

Originally Posted by Serancha

Giving it to just officers and GM's would add to the already-large problem of guild segregation. I know a lot of guilds don't see members as equal to ranked members, in the sense that officers only run with officers and use /o instead of /g most of the time. I was in a guild like that once, and have heard that it is still the norm in a lot of guilds.

Giving banners to those who are already often treated as (or consider themselves) "better" than others in the guild would just enhance this problem and make everyone else feel left out. After all, it's the members who get the guild it's ranking. If it were just officers, these top guilds would not be "top".

Yup

**Andrisber** · 01-18-2015, 05:41 PM

Originally Posted by Serancha

Giving it to just officers and GM's would add to the already-large problem of guild segregation. I know a lot of guilds don't see members as equal to ranked members, in the sense that officers only run with officers and use /o instead of /g most of the time. I was in a guild like that once, and have heard that it is still the norm in a lot of guilds.

Giving banners to those who are already often treated as (or consider themselves) "better" than others in the guild would just enhance this problem and make everyone else feel left out. After all, it's the members who get the guild it's ranking. If it were just officers, these top guilds would not be "top".

Uhm... If someone joined 1 day before the season ends and gets a banner, it wouldn't be fair too

**Serancha** · 01-19-2015, 02:04 PM

Originally Posted by Andrisber

Uhm... If someone joined 1 day before the season ends and gets a banner, it wouldn't be fair too

So you see the problem then. If you just give banners to ranked members, it's unfair. GM's could also cheat and temporarily promote a bunch of people just for the banners. Or else you give the banners to everyone and have people joining just for a day or a week so they can get banners. Either way it's not going to work.

**Hakdog** · 03-06-2020, 05:15 AM

Originally Posted by Serancha

So you see the problem then. If you just give banners to ranked members, it's unfair. GM's could also cheat and temporarily promote a bunch of people just for the banners. Or else you give the banners to everyone and have people joining just for a day or a week so they can get banners. Either way it's not going to work.

its really unfair for me