Maybe I'm Missing Something: How to Make Treat Bags from Candy Bars?

[Fyrce]

I have this:


My craft menu says this:


When I craft, the recipe disappears, I get a Treat Bag and the Candy bars are never used...
I know because I did this already. And spent tokens to buy the Recipe.
So when are Candy Bars used to make 2018 Treat Bags? I would rather use Candy bars than 50 tokens per Treat Bag.