As a player who "only" has 110m pure and like 250-300m in items - and therefore being far away from having enough for BD set - I can see both points.

But I must say, the arguments from the old players are just better so far.

Noone stated a real good reason to bring back old items yet. "Everyone is so selfish..." is not an argument. What is funny, is that the "I didn't read your arguments because I know I what I'm talking about/ aka I don't count other opinions" statements sound even more selfish.

BUT to be fair, the "bring back only very few of it to not destroy the value" idea actually sounds like a possible compromise.

For example:
Make an event with ultra rare drops of BD Helm and Armor pieces. You need 5 different parts to be able to craft BD Helm or Armor. After 10 (?) sets have been crafted, the drops stop.

(That would spread the value a bit more than giving it to top 10 pro players in an event who most likely are too rich already).