Quote Originally Posted by papas View Post
As I mentioned before guild age must be a factor. Always in history "ancient" guilds or clans are highly respected. Existing for so many years must be counted. New guilds have option to exclude this factor for lb if is the worse. This was desided long ago by devs which was the smartest thing abt guild lb.
Maybe some don't know this. The best and worse rank(tatal of two) of factors are being excluded so will be a bit balanse to new guilds. Also this helps if one guild "cheats" so will get not legit pvp or pve kills and gets insase numbers and rank1 of one factor.
Inactive characters not to be counted for rank sounds not bad idea. So some guilds with 5-20% activity will go off lb.
Pve / pvp factors must remain. There are so many ppl tha have high numbers LEGIT. Even some guilds dummy farmed millions of pvp kills to get high rank. This should be dealt by devs. Banning em for 1week without removing those kills didn't work. Sinse same person kept dummy farm more hundreds of thousands without get punished this time. Dummy farm till 10k kills should not be punished.
Rewarding top guilds would mess things up. Many guilds will find ways to cheat, more drama will come, and hundreds of mails will received by devs reporting cheaters. Guild lb can never be legit 100%
Saying this by GM of CU being(legit) top guild in lb 90% of time the last 3years.

Στάλθηκε από το LDN-L21 μου χρησιμοποιώντας Tapatalk
That's why have to change the table. So that it is legitimate, and prizes can be given. Why punish people if you can modify, the way it works.
And seniority is an unnecessary advantage. I am not a better or more active player, for playing longer. And I've been playing for 7 years.
It's simple, players who don't play shouldn't participate in the competition, much less those who stopped playing more than 1 year ago.
As you can see the other Lb are reset every season, only purely active players participate. Nor does it matter how old the players are in the others Lb.
You also have hundreds of new players, who participate in the seasonal Lb, with full aps. Are those players less important because they are new characters?
Also in a real competition everyone starts from the same goal.
So far you haven't given a single good reason why those parameters should stay.
If they're a good guild they don't need those perks to prove it. What are you afraid of?