Let's look at the rogue, since love posted those stats.
So, we gained crit instead of damage. Let's see what that does for us, according to this post: http://www.spacetimestudios.com/show...l=1#post989612 crits do about 125% of normal damage (an increase of 25%). I'm sure, without even doing the math, you can see how that does not add up to an increase of double the damage and that's without even counting in the 344% bonus damage that would have been applied to that extra 3 dmg.
Bookmarks